Caribbean Eggnog, aka Coquito at the Friday Afternoon Happy Hour!

Caribbean Eggnog Coquito coverIt is hard to keep track of seasons when the high temperature in summer and winter only fluctuates 5 degrees… Summer high is 88-90ish and in winter the high is 83-85ish degrees. SO when I had the realization yesterday that Thanksgiving is in one week, I nearly had a heart attack!! I am not ready!!

Rather than panicking, I invited my friend Jenny over, and we mixed up a batch of Caribbean Eggnog, or better known here in Puerto Rico as coquito!! What better way to get in the Christmas spirit and get us ready for all the holiday craziness, than to mix up a yummy treat that is loaded with coconut, cinnamon and best of all… rum!!

There are many versions of this recipe, and every family has their favorite. After polling my local Puerto Rican friends a few years ago regarding egg vs. no egg, how much of each ingredients, etc., I came up with this version that has no eggs in it and it is absolutely delicious!!

Here in Puerto Rico, coquito is given as Christmas gifts to friends and neighbors. The bottles that you see in the pictures are (18 oz) coquito bottles that you can pick up at any grocery store – here in PR that is – this time of year. I’m sure that there are plenty of other options that will work just fine back in the states. I like to put the majority of my coquito batch that I am saving for myself in a empty liquor bottle. It is easier to store one bigger bottle than to have 6 smaller ones rolling around in my fridge. I usually also fill 3-4 smaller bottles so that I have a few to give as gifts.

Note: Here in Puerto Rico, the commonly held belief is that it isn’t real coquito unless it is made with Don Q Crystal Rum. Before moving to the island I preferred Bacardi or Captain for my mixed drinks, but since moving here I have succumb to the belief that Don Q is amazing!! If you haven’t tried it you really need to, it is a real Puerto Rican rum and it is delicious!

Caribbean Eggnog coquito bottlesHere is what you will need to mix up a batch of your very own “liquid holiday cheer” for your next get-together:

2 cans of cream of coconut, 15 oz cans
1 can of coconut milk, 14 oz can
1 can of sweetened condensed milk, 14 oz can
2 cups Don Q Crystal rum (or white rum of choice)
2 tsp vanilla
2 tsp ground cinnamon, plus a little for garnish
6-8 cinnamon sticks
bottles to store your coquito in for the fridge or to use as gifts.

Caribbean Eggnog Coquito ingredientsI like to mix up the batch in a tall plastic pitcher with a wand mixer. I usually only mix one batch at a time even when I make a double batch that day because it is easier to mix, and keeps it from sloshing out while you are blending. It is also easier to pour it into the bottles when you are using a pitcher.

Add all your liquids to the pitcher and use the mixer to combine them. While the mixer is running, sprinkle a little of the ground cinnamon at a time into the pitcher and thoroughly blend to combine. If you add all the ground cinnamon at once it tends to clump into little balls, and it takes a lot of extra mixing to smooth it out.

Caribbean Eggnog Coquito mixingPour coquito into bottles and add 2 whole cinnamon sticks to each 18 oz bottle. For the large liquor bottle I added 5-6 cinnamon sticks. Store in the refrigerator.

Caribbean Eggnog coquito pouring into bottle

Note: The coquito should last all season in your refrigerator (4-6 months).  Versions that include eggs or other ingredients might not last as long so please do not apply that time frame to other recipes.

Serve cold with no ice, or if you are impatient like me and want a glass right after you mix it up, you can serve over ice. Another option would be to shake it with ice in a drink shaker, and pour into a martini glass. It was a warm day so ice in the coquito just sounded a little more refreshing.  😉

Right now, as Jenny and I head off to the beach this morning, I am wishing for a little cooler weather to help bring on the holiday feeling. Hopefully I will get a cold blast when Tavis, Aiden and I head North, to Southwest Florida for Christmas in a few weeks!! :)

5.0 from 2 reviews
Caribbean Eggnog Coquito
Recipe type: Cocktail
Cuisine: Caribbean
Prep time: 
Total time: 
Serves: 12-16 servings
  • 2 cans of cream of coconut (15 oz)
  • 1 can of coconut milk (14 oz)
  • 1 can of sweetened condensed milk (14 oz)
  • 2 cups Don Q rum (white rum)
  • 2 tsp vanilla
  • 2 tsp ground cinnamon (plus a little for garnish)
  • 6 cinnamon sticks
  • bottles to store your coquito in for the fridge or to use as gifts.
  1. Add all liquid ingredients to pitcher and mix with hand blender.
  2. Slowly add ground cinnamon while mixing to avoid clumps.
  3. Pour coquito into bottles and add 2 cinnamon sticks to each bottle, or 5-6 for a large bottle.
  4. Serve cold or over ice.
  5. Keep coquito refrigerated.

Caribbean Eggnog Coquito finished drink

Don’t miss out on any new posts or recipes, sign up for our email list here! Don’t worry we don’t sell your address or give it to anyone and you will only get emails when a new post goes up. :)



  1. Vicki says:

    Hello Ashley, what is the recipe for Caribbean eggnog please?

  2. Ashley can you tell where to get the self-capping bottles pictured on your blog? I have been looking for these for gifts! tia…….Tasha

    • Ashley says:

      Tasha, Here in Puerto Rico they sell them everywhere this time of year (grocery stores, Walgreens, Sam’s Club…). If I remember correctly I got this box of 6 bottles at Sam’s. If you have a local store that specializes in Hispanic foods they might sell them as well. If all else fails I found these bottles that are similar on amazon. Let me know where you end up getting them!! :)

  3. Mimi says:

    So Yummy! Thanks for the recipe Ashley!

  4. For some reason it seems too sweet. Was I correct to put 2 -15oz cans in drink. 15oz each can.

    • Ashley says:

      Yes!! It is a very sweet drink, kind of like a dessert drink. I usually enjoy it after dinner or on a special holday morning, I put some in my coffee rather than creamer, YUM!! Enjoy :)

  5. Claire Santiago says:

    I got the bottles at Hobby Lobby.
    My coquito is REALLY thick. Can I add something to thin it out?


  1. […] Caribbean Eggnog (Coquito): Fun Puerto Rican Holiday Drink made with coconut milk. (via Living the […]

  2. […] Sparkling Apple Cider Sangria 2. Easy Thanksgiving Drink Recipes 3. Carribbean Eggnog 4. Whiskey Espresso 5. Candy Cane Cooler Cocktail 6. Kentucky Christmas Cocktail with Candied […]

Speak Your Mind


Rate this recipe:  

Privacy & Disclosure